Thursday , 18 September 2014
Learn What SSDs Can Do For You:

MacBook Air (mid-2012) MBA Review Part 2 – Samsung and Toshiba (SandForce) SSDs Go Head To Head

Following up on our first MacBook Air Review a few days back, we couldn’t resist getting a second MBA in our hands to pair off both the Samsung and Toshiba SSDs in a head to head battle of speed and performance.

The Toshiba SSD is LSI SandForce controlled and should excel in typical user performance , whereas, we would expect to see the Samsung pulling ahead with respect to it’s transfer of incompressible data such as movies, music and photos.

Early indications at Anandtech, however, seem to have shown listed specifications below norm for the typical ‘LSI SandForce Driven’ solid state drive.  Transfer speeds of 490MB/s and 340MB/s seemed to be lower than anything we had seen with the LSI SandForce SF-2281 6Gbps processor yet.  As I had stated in our first report though, I am new to the world of Mac/OS X and storage testing just isn’t the same in the Mac realm so nothing would surprise me.

Couple that with rumors that OS X and SandForce were like oil and water when it came to getting TRIM to work and, even with SandForce’ great garbage collection ability, I never expected to find a ‘LSI SandForce Driven’ SSD in an Apple. Nobody had a clue.

As it appears now, many are reporting that capacities of 64 and 128GB seem to be Toshiba SSDs with 256 and 512 capacities belonging to Samsung.  Identification can only be confirmed after purchase by following ‘Apple Icon/About This Mac/More Info/System Report and clicking on Serial-ATA‘. The SSD will be labeled as APPLE SSD ‘SM’ for Samsung or ‘TS’ for Toshiba.

TOSHIBA 128GB SATA 3 COMPONENTS

The Toshiba THNSNS128GMFP is a ‘gumstick’ style SSD and it’s SATA connector is proprietary to Apple and, more specifically, proprietary to only new Apple systems released mid-2012.  Apple has made sure that, not only can we not switch off the SSD with a third party SSD but also, we can’t even switch off the SSD with 2010 Mac release product SSDs. Clicking on any photo will bring up a higher resolution photograph.

The Toshiba branded controller bears the markings of SandForce which would logically make it a SF-2281 6Gbps controller capable of performance in excess of 500MB/s read and write.  This MBA is a 128GB version and the SSD contains four modules of 32GB Toshiba Toggle Mode 24nm NAND flash memory for a total RAW capacity of 128GB.

Typically, 8GB of that memory would be proprietary to SandForce over provisioning and firmware needs which would leave the advertised capacities of 120G.

MBA CONFIGURATION

The configurations of both MBA’s differed with respect to our test protocol.  The system used in the first review was an Intel Core i7 Ivy Bridge processor with 8GB RAM and a 256GB Samsung SSD while the system in use for this review is an Intel Core i5 Ivy Bridge processor, 4GB RAM and the 128GB Toshiba SSD.  While the CPU and RAM will not affect storage performance at all, the performance advantage should go to the Samsung PM830 256GB SSD as its higher capacity followed with increased performance specifications, compared to the Toshiba 128GB SSD.

This was a necessary evil, however, as we have already related our belief that 64 and 128GB capacities of the MBA seem to be Toshiba while 256 and 512 capacities seem to be Samsung SSDs.  There is no identification on the outside of the sealed packaging and absolutely no way to confirm prior to purchase and actually seeing the identification for oneself.

BENCHMARK SOFTWARE

The software we will be using for today’s analysis is typical of many of our reviews and consist of ATTO Disk Benchmark, Crystal DiskMark, AS SSD, Anvil Storage Utilities, and PCMark Vantage.  We rely on these as they each have a way of supporting one another yet, at the same time, adding a new performance benchmark to the total picture.  Much of the software is free and can be downloaded simply by clicking on the linked title.

About Les Tokar

is a technology nut and Founder of The SSD Review. His early work includes the first consumer SSD review along with MS Vista, Win 7 and SSD Optimization Guides. Les is fortunate to, not only evaluate and provide opinion on consumer and enterprise solid state storage but also, travel the world in search of new technologies and great friendships. Google+
  • Nox

    :) Thank you so much for this excellent review, exquisite not only in
    its findings but also in terms of the amazingly simplistic manner in
    which you presented the essential facts and clearly bring about the
    important distinctions between the Toshiba SandForce Driven SSD and the
    Samsung SSD to light. As a novice to SSD’s and the MBA alike, your
    findings have not only made it easier for me to choose the MBA with the specs that fits my budget, I also no longer feel like I’m getting a “lesser deal for my buck” from Apple by choosing one blindly over the other, something that I was thinking of considering in 2011, while being at the same crossroads as I find myself today.

    Last year I had decided NOT to opt for the MBA, considering the vast difference in the performance between the Toshiba & Samsung SSD’s & having no way to determine how to go about choosing the best SSD without leaving things to fate! As usual, the “Genie-Ass’s” @ Apple were of No help at all-Many did not even know what I was talking about! This year, thanks to your review, I find myself better equipped and more empowered to make the right decision!

    In light of Apple’s known business practice of “discrimination” in sourcing SSD’s from two different vendors and not giving a choice to the end user as to which SSD we want to purchase at the point of sale, your review breathes new hope & light in the current scenario by empowering the end user with the required information so that we get to know what we’re paying for and helping us set our “expectations” accordingly.

    I’m also grateful to you for investing your time & effort in publishing your findings in record time & thanks for not taking your reader’s patience for granted, unlike some of your colleagues in the same industry! Like last year, I was waiting for Anandtech for publishing their in-depth review for the 2012 MBA’s & it’s SSD to finally decide if one was worth switching to this year, and after waiting for what seemed to be an eternity, it looked like Anand had found his dream machine in the new Retina MBP and having reviewed it thoroughly, he & his team seemed uninterested in helping prospective MBA buyers this year.. they may be hard at work on it right now-I don’t know & I no longer care but I’m surely glad I stumbled upon you site and got the information I was looking for! Thanks a ton!!! :)

    • http://www.thessdreview.com Les@TheSSDReview

      Thank you for that detailed return and glad we could help!

  • http://twitter.com/Social_Quotient John Curtis

    Perfect drive to offload outlook ost file and windows search index :)

  • Dexter

    @Les: Thanks for the review.. Quick question:Since you have both the MBA’s 128GB/256GB with you, can you please check & let us know which panels(Samsung/LG) do they have & your comments about the visible contrast & color vibrancy difference on both-I know I’m requesting this info on theSSDreivew site & reviewing panels is by no means your primary focus but i’ll be extremely grateful if you can help me (& others like me) with this since I can’t seem to be able to get a clear answer from other websites & forums to help me decide if I’ll be okay with getting an LG Panel, as it’s all a lottery anyways! Thanks a ton, in anticipation!

  • Vineet

    Hi,
    I have a question.. I have X1 Carbon (2012). I am looking to upgrade my ssd to higher capacity. Can you please suggest which would be the best and the cheapest ?

Footer 930x64
SSD QUICK SEARCH